20 Easy Christmas Peanut Butter Fudge Recipes

Get into the holiday spirit with these exciting and delicious Christmas peanut butter fudge recipes. These easy-to-make treats are perfect for a festive holiday celebration. Prepare to wow your family and friends with these tasty fudge recipes made with creamy peanut butter this holiday season.

More collections: Christmas Vegetable Salads, Canning Christmas Recipes, Christmas Ham Recipes, Christmas Mulled Wine, Christmas Candy Brittle Recipe, Christmas Chocolate Bark, Christmas Chocolate Fudge

How can you forget to make treats and candies for Christmas? We can't let your holidays get ruined like this! There will be so many guests dropping by now and then! Kids and little ones accompany their parents to your parties, events, and gatherings! You can not let them be sad and bored while the adults enjoy the evening!

It is fine if you missed the nitty-gritty amidst all the stress and preparations. You can still make it up to them with the wonderful fudge recipes that are here waiting for you! Simple, yummy, and ready in a jiffy, you must go through these lovely peanut butter recipes that are waiting for you right here! But before that, do not forget to check out the tips too!

Things you should know about making fudges during the holidays

If you are worried that much of your time will be consumed in the process, then we can help you out with that! Fudges are the best thing one can think of! Delicious and small, you can enjoy them anytime you want.

What are the basic ingredients to indulge in?

You may opt for red sugar, brown sugar, and cream are some of the main components of fudges. A bit of vanilla essence, maple, and nuts can confer a great deal of taste to the homemade fudges, and you will hardly be able to distinguish them from the store-bought ones. Icing, corn syrup, and marshmallows are some of the extra ingredients that go in depending on the recipe that you follow.

What is the kind of texture that you can expect?

Fudges generally are soft and tender with a silky texture, but they should not fall apart or turn runny when left outside at room temperature.  So you can expect the texture of the fudge to be smooth but not too tough at the same time!

There is, of course, a specific technique for making them; let's learn about that first. Cooking in heat is essential so that the sugar crystals dissolve and give a smooth texture to the fudges! It is also vital for the evaporation of the excess water in the syrup as well. This is to be noted that evaporation of water turns the fudge tough, and the cooking time is prolonged.

The absence of evaporation can leave the syrup wet and difficult to mold in a particular shape. To ensure that water evaporates well and that the sugar gets concentrated optimally, you need to maintain the temperature from 112°C to 114°C (234°F to 237°F).

Do not miss out on a candy thermometer.

There is one thing that you must ensure! The temperature is maintained constant and followed throughout the process, or the texture and taste of the fudges will get affected. To do so, you need a candy thermometer! This will ensure that you maintain accuracy! However, do not touch the thermometer to the bottom or side of the pan, or the readings will not be right.

Pro Tips-

• This is to be noted that stirring while the fudge syrup has come to a simmer will affect the consistency of the liquid and must be avoided at all costs.

• Beating is needed once the fudge solution cools down. Allow the mixture to cool for about fifteen minutes before you engage in the process of beating the solution. A wooden spatula is good enough to do the job.

• You should always use a heavy bottom pan so that the syrup does not get burnt at high heat.

Delicious Christmas Peanut Butter Fudge Recipes for the Holidays

1. Easy peanut butter fudge

Smooth, savory, and rich, the Christmas peanut butter fudge is flooded with great taste!

Delectable and lovely, you should get it done during the holidays. What an incredible creation!

2. Easy and delicious Buckeye fudge

The awesome buckeye fudge is an exclusive creation and leaves one tempted for more.

Savory and fascinating, if you are in the mood for fudge, then go ahead with this idea right away! So what are you waiting for? Make it today!

3. The best-ever peanut butter fudge

All you need are three ingredients to come up with the rich peanut butter fudge!

Luxurious and smooth, you must indulge in the blissful experience of delicious fudge. So let's get started with the preps, shall we? Let's go!

4. Easy chocolate peanut butter fudge swirl recipe

The combination of peanut butter and chocolate is a match made in heaven.

Rich and intricate, the chocolate fudge is delicious, and when combined with peanut butter, the fudge turns out to be the showstopper of the event.

5. Reese's fudge recipe

Delicious and sweet, Reese's fudge recipe is a smooth and savory one leaving you asking for more.

Chewy and easy to make, the dish is so easy to prepare. So let's get started with the preps already, shall we?

Thank you for this amazing idea right here.

6. Root beer fudge

The rich and luxurious root beer fudge is as tempting as you can think of!

Packed with the rich flavors of marshmallows, the creamy and tender fudges are the best for the holidays!

So shall we get started then?

7. Homemade fluffernutter fudge

The homemade fluffernutter fudge is another wonderful idea topped with marshmallows!

Chewy and savory, the recipe turns out to be an exclusive treat for dessert lovers!

Perfect to match the ambiance of the winter! So, shall we try it then?

8. Fantasy chocolate peanut butter fudge

The chocolate Christmas peanut butter fudge is an extraordinary creation and leaves you with an amazing aftertaste in your mouth! Rich and gooey, the recipe is a marvelous idea as small bite-sized appetizers keep you company. Shall we try it, then?

9. Tiger butter fudge

If you haven't tried the Tiger butter fudge yet, then you should go ahead with this recipe!

Savory and creamy, the fudge turns out to be an exclusive treat! And the best part is that the fudge is so easy to curate.

10. White chocolate caramel fudge

The white chocolate caramel fudge is a wonderful idea and such a gooey treat, indeed!

Let's not waste a single second and begin with the preparation as the holidays are almost about to get over.

11. Peanut butter and jelly fudge( only five ingredients)

Beautiful to even look at, the rich peanut butter and jelly fudge is a treat for both eyes and taste buds.

And the best part is you only need five ingredients to come up with this recipe! So what are you waiting for? Get it done today!

12. Creamy, old-fashioned butter pecan fudge

The creamy pecan fudge is right here to sway you off your feet! No, we aren't exaggerating, not even a bit!

But you do not have to take our word for it; try it out on your own and find out!

13. Creamy peanut butter fudge

Adorned with colorful M&Ms, the creamy peanut butter fudge is a lovely curation, we must admit.

Recipes like these are what we live and die for! And that is fine if this is your first time making fudge at home; you have found the right recipe.

14. Peppermint bark fudge

The exclusive peppermint bar fridge recipe always makes its way to the top of the priority list when it comes to Christmas!

Delicious and chewy, you ought to indulge in its blissful taste.

15. Healthy chocolate peanut butter fudge

There is nothing that can beat the duo of peanut butter and chocolate, especially when we are baking fudges!

Rich, decadent, and creamy, everyone at the party will waste no time picking up their shares.

16. Mint Oreo cookie and cream fudge

Once we came across the Mint Oreo cookie and cream fudge, we knew it had to make it to the list!

Delicious and delightful, you can serve them as small appetizers to the guests as they gather for the grand celebrations.

17. No-bake peanut butter cup freezer fudge

Yup, that is right! You can end up making the Christmas peanut butter fudge at home! The recipe is pretty simple and hardly requires any effort!

And the best part is you do not even have to spend time in front of the oven baking them. Just freeze and go!

18. Delicious hot cocoa fudge

Here comes the delectable hot cocoa fudge that you can enjoy with tender marshmallows on top!

Savory and luxurious, instead of having cocoa in the glass, have it in the form of fudge!

19. White chocolate peanut butter Reese's fudge

Let's not forget that Christmas is all about merriment, treats, and candies!

The luxurious texture of the fudges makes them melt in your mouth and leave you tempted for more and more.

So what are you waiting for?

20. Double-decker chocolate peanut butter fudges

The gorgeous double-decker chocolate peanut butter fudge is an extraordinary creation!

Be prepared to go weak down your knees with the recipe that we have for you right here.

So are you ready? Then put on your chef's hat and join us.

Other recipes you should check out: Chocolate Cake Recipes, Christmas Candy Recipes, Fudge Recipes, Halloween Caramel Apples, Instant Pot Pork Tenderloin Recipes, Instant Pot Recipes For Beginners, Christmas Beef Tenderloin Recipes