Halloween Cookies: 20 Recipes to Make Your Spooky Season Sweeter

Get in the spooky season spirit with delicious Halloween cookies recipes! Perfect for parties, family fun, or a sweet treat, satisfy your sweet tooth this Halloween with these unique and tasty cookie ideas. Try one today!

More collections: Halloween Snacks, Halloween Pumpkin Dip Recipes, Pumpkin Seeds Recipes, Halloween Main Dishes, Halloween Leftover Candy Recipes, Halloween Cakes, Halloween Pumpkin Rolls

Well, cookies and cupcakes go hand in hand when the season of Halloween is knocking at the doors! The houses are decked up and treats are prepared to escalate the joy of the occasion! Every other day we have a party to attend or a flock of friends visiting us now and then!

So this season if you were planning to make something as a token of affection for your friends and family, then there is nothing better than cookie baskets! It is time for you to bake some cookies at home.

What is the need to soften the butter and cream it?

If you are baking cookies for the first time at home then you might not be aware of the purpose of creaming. This is to be noted that every recipe asks us to soften the butter and allow it to be a bit molten before it is added to the mixture bowl!

Hence you are recommended to bring the butter cubes out of the refrigerator about an hour before you start! Creaming is the process that is done at the beginning of mixing! Here the semi-solid butter is whisked with sugar until a creamy consistency is reached. Creaming ensures that the butter can trap enough air bubbles which will later be useful to make your cookies light and flaky.

Is seasoning required for cookies?

We have observed several recipes where it is mandatory for you to season your cookie dough with a pinch of salt! It acts as a taste enhancer! But that does not mean if you forgot to season, your cookies will be an absolute disaster. Seasoning is an extra effort that is taken to ensure that your cookies turn out to be even more tasteful.

Which is better non-stick baking sheets or parchment paper?

If you are confused about which one to choose then we have the right answer for you right here! This is to be noted that although parchment paper is very cheap and affordable, it is not completely non-stick! On the other hand, baking sheets are a one-time investment but they last forever and are totally non-stick too!

In the middle of baking, you can accidentally get over with a parchment paper roll and run to the stores at peak hours may not be the ideal situation for us. Hence, bakers and experts, these days are stocking their kitchens with baking sheets instead.

How can you prevent your cookies from spreading?

You are expected to freeze the cookie dough and allow it to chill in the refrigerator for at least an hour! If you have no time constraint, then overnight is the best option. During its time inside the refrigerator, the ingredients mingle with one another and the cookie dough acquires a firm and strong consistency. Later when you bake the cookies, they will not spread too much on the tray and remain in their shape!

But what if they are not spreading at all?

See, there are two extremes that must be avoided! Over and under spreading! Just like excess spreading where your cookies will lose their shape and form, under spreading can make your cookies extra hard and chewy! If you observe such a situation then you need to bring out the tray from the oven a couple of times and beat the sheet against the kitchen counter. This will ensure that your cookies are spreading adequately.

Well, that is more or less everything you had to know before you baked the cookies at home.

Halloween Cookie Recipes That Will Have You Begging for More

1. Halloween pinwheel cookies

The vibrant and yummy pinwheel cookies are simply the best! If you are a beginner in baking then this recipe is very useful and comes in handy!

Try them out this holiday season and let us know how much you liked these pinwheel cookies.

2. Milk chocolate stuffed jack-o-lantern cookies

These jack-o-lantern cookies look anything but scary! Adorable rather, the eyes and the smile are filled with liquid milk chocolate while the crust tastes equally divine.

What a magnificent treat for the taste buds we must admit!

3. Halloween sugar cookies

How can we miss out on the all-time classic, the sugar cookies?

Here is a vibrant batch that will make you drool for them at the very first bite.

Crumbly and cozy, you will soon find the jar empty as the kids will steal them all!

4. Halloween cutout cookies

This holiday we decided to try out cutout cookies and when we came across this recipe of cutout cookies we knew this recipe would make it to the list.

So what are you waiting for?  Bake it today!

5. Witch Hat Halloween cookies

The delicious and colorful Witch Hat Halloween cookies with Hershey's Kiss in the center look so gorgeous and tempting on the table!

You will be surprised to find out how quickly they get over in a jiffy! So shall we bake them then?

6. Crumble dirt cake cookies

Have you tried to crumble dirt cookies before? Well, if you haven't then you should with the recipe that makes it so easy for one to emulate them!

Topped with frosting and jelly worms, this is best suited to the Halloween season.

7. Hocus Pocus cookies filled with witch's brew frosting

Now we can guarantee what kind of spell the witches have cast upon these cookies! It is upon you to find out!

Overall, the cookies look quite tempting to lure the kids to try out this one just like how the witches do!

8. Crumble pumpkin pie cookies

Here is another wonderful treat for the season! The rich and crunchy pumpkin pie cookies are ready in no time!

Savory and packed with great flavors, the cookies turn out to be an extraordinary idea!

9. Easy sprinkle Halloween cookies

The sprinkled Halloween cookies are simply the best and leave you tempted for more!

Drizzled with all the treats which you find wonderful, the Halloween cookies are the best and need no words to describe them!

Go for it today!

10. Dark chocolate Halloween chip cookies

If you are looking for something rich and cozy, then you should try out these amazing dark chocolate Halloween cookies!

Crumbly, creamy, and drizzled with which chocolate chips, this complements the taste of the cookies so well. Do give it a try!

11. The best chewy pumpkin snickerdoodles

The chewy pumpkin cookies are wanted to celebrate the season of fall! Flooded with delightful taste, you simply can't stop yourself at one!

Try out these cookies with tea and serve them when you have guests as well.

12. Spooky eye cookies

The spooky eye cookies are perfect and suited to the theme of the occasion!

Flooded with great taste, you will definitely be tempted to reach out for more.

These cookies are fantastic and guess what even beginners can try their hands at this one.

13. Crumble Reese's peanut butter cookies

We have another wonderful treat for you to relish this season! The gorgeous Crumble Reese's peanut butter cookies are the best!

Smooth, chewy, and tender, it fulfills all the superior qualities of being the most outstanding cookies in the world.

14. Peanut butter Butterfinger cookies

The rich and creamy peanut butter cookies are right here to sway one off their feet! This recipe is wonderful and ready in no time!

Savory and rich in flavor, these cookies are the best thing we came across this season and knew it had to show up on the list.

15. Roly Poly pumpkin cookies

We are talking about the graceful and elegant Roly poly cookies which are not only a treat to the taste buds but also a delightful sight for the eyes to encounter!

You must prepare and display them on the table at the Halloween gathering.

16. Halloween melt-away cookies

Here is another idea to make your holidays even more exciting and cheerful with the Halloween melt-away cookies that we have for you right here.

Crispy and drizzled with loads of sprinkles.

17. Lofthouse copycat sugar cookies

You will be amazed to find out that making sugar cookies of this kind is not only enriching for the taste buds but also such an exciting and refreshing experience to bake them all by yourself.

18. Chocolate caramel stuffed cookies

The gooey caramel in the center of the cookies tastes so yummy! These cookies are full of surprises inside as well as outside.

But with so many cookie monsters loitering around the neighborhood during the holidays, we don't know how long you can save them.

19. Halloween sugar cookies

If you are planning to bake cookies this season then do not miss out on the gorgeous Halloween sugar cookies that we have for you right here.

Savory and smooth, the cookies are best to try out!

20. Air fryer Oreos

Yup, you heard it right! The air fryer Oreos are actually possible! Rich and crumbly, these cookies are an absolute show-stopper!

Packed with great flavors, the Oreo cookies are simply the best and leave ones tempted for more. Shall we then?

Other Halloween ideas you should check out: Halloween Dessert Recipes, Christmas Cookies Recipes, Valentine's Day Cookies Recipes, Christmas Baking Recipes, Cake Batter Cookie Recipes, Bundt Cake Recipes, Halloween Witch Decor Ideas, Halloween Lighting Decor Ideas, Spooky Halloween Wreaths, Halloween Table Decor Ideas