Thanksgiving Cookies: 20 Top Recipes to Make This Holiday Season

Sweeten your Thanksgiving celebration with these easy Thanksgiving cookie recipes. Learn how to make classic, favorite flavors plus unique variations on traditional favorites. Enjoy a tasty holiday with the best Thanksgiving cookies this season.

More collections: Thanksgiving Potluck, Thanksgiving Cheesecake Recipes, Keto Thanksgiving Recipes, Thanksgiving Bread Recipes, Vegan Thanksgiving Recipes, Thanksgiving Cake Recipes, Thanksgiving Cupcakes, Thanksgiving Soups, Thanksgiving Salad Recipes, Thanksgiving Breakfast Recipes, Thanksgiving Appetizers

When you are in the mood for cookies and simply cannot resist yourself, here is some good news for you! Baking cookies can seem very easy at first but even the slightest mistake can ruin the texture and flavors of the same.

However, it is not a Herculean task either! If you follow the recipes and tips properly then you are about to be surprised with fresh and crispy batches of cookies during the holidays! So put on your hats and mitten, as we will learn to bake cookies!

Why should all the ingredients be present at room temperature?

Often while baking you must have read that in the instructions column, the ingredients are asked to be placed at room temperature. Now you must be wondering why it is so necessary! Well, to answer your question, we need to understand that cold ingredients are relatively very hard to blend. Imagine a hard lump of butter!

Yup, it will be very difficult to blend! While you cream the butter, the semi-solid texture helps to trap some air particles. Similarly, eggs are needed at room temperature so that the cookies can turn out to be fluffy and crunchy! On the other hand, cold eggs are of no good use as these simply fail to do their job well.

What do you mean by creaming the butter?

Now if you feel that creaming is an ordinary step in making cookies then you are certainly going to regret saying so! Creaming is the first step in making cookies and if you skip this step then chances are you will end up with chewy and dense cookies.

During creaming, the semi-solid butter is whisked well with sugar, and a smooth consistency is acquired! Do you know what happens here? In this process, the air is trapped in the butter which is later useful during baking leaving your cookies flaky and crunchy all at once.

Is it essential to season your cookies?

This is to be noted that seasoning is not just for savory dishes but also desserts need to be seasoned properly. Have you tried the salted caramel flavor before? Well, it would not be so good if there was no salt in the caramel syrup. Salt goes great with chocolates as well! Hence the next time you are planning to bake cookies, do not shy away from seasoning them with some salt too.

Which is better baking mats or parchment paper

When we are talking about baking mats, let us tell you that they are way better and a modern innovation for baking! Do you know why? This is to be noted that parchment papers are not completely non-stick and they might get soaked in oil, neither are they reusable!

So in case, if you get over with parchment paper in the middle of the baking session then you might not have ample time to rush to the stores. Baking sheets on the other hand are a one-time investment as you can clean and reuse them again and again. They are totally non-stick and there shall be no fear of running out of them in the middle of the task.

What are some of the toppings that you can use with cookies

Literally whatever you wish can be added to your cookies! From chocolate chips to chunks and pieces, white chocolate chips, and so on. One can even opt for nuts, seeds, or colorful sprinkles, and the options are simply endless.

Here are some gorgeous and easy cookie recipes for Thanksgiving.

The Best Thanksgiving Cookies Recipes - Delicious Sweet Treats

1. Chai spiced maple sugar cookie with brown butter frosting

Delicious, crumbly, and savory, you are definitely going to fall in love with the extraordinary cookies which are carved out as fall leaves! Isn't it fascinating?

2. Pumpkin cheesecake snickerdoodle cookies

Did you try out these Snickerdoodle cookies yet? Because if you haven't then you are certainly up for a surprise.

Filled with yummy cheesecake in the center, the recipe is truly gorgeous in every bite. Enjoy it with a cup of tea.

3. Healthy pumpkin chocolate chip cookies

The pumpkin chocolate chip cookies are simply the best! Crumbly, crunchy and rich, you are surely going to enjoy this idea as the fall season invites you to experience its blooms.

Make a large batch so you have enough to last the season.

4. Crumble pecan pie cookies

Did you try the crumbled pecan pie cookies yet? If you haven't then quickly put on your hats and back this detectable treat right away!

So what are you waiting for? Make this one right away and enjoy it to your fullest.

5. Butter pecan cookies

The butter pecan cookies are delectable and flooded with the smoothness of butter!

Gorgeous and topped with pecan crunch, do give it a try right away! Ready in no time, you are surely going to enjoy every bite.

6. Pumpkin cookies with cinnamon sugar

Ah, what an incredible creation! Drizzled with sugar and flavored with cinnamon essence, you are definitely going to enjoy this one!

The pulpy pumpkin essence is wonderful and truly a great source of joy for the taste buds! Make it quickly. Shall we try it then?

7. Pumpkin cutout sugar cookies

These sugar cookies are crumbly and crunchy in every bite. Cozy and rich, the pumpkin cutout sugar cookies are delectable and flooded with great taste!

Perfect to go with a cup of tea in the fall evening.  Shall we?

8. Maple brown cookies

The delicious and sweet maple brown cookies are fabulous and packed with a sweet essence!

These cookies are ready in no time and you can enjoy them throughout the holiday season. Shall we give it a try then?

What a gorgeous idea to be honest.

9. Pumpkin spice oatmeal cookies

The delicious and crumbly pumpkin spice cookies are lovely and you must try it out!

Savory and sweet, these cookies are perfectly suited to the season of Thanksgiving! Bake it quickly and enjoy it to your fullest. Shall we then?

10. The iced pumpkin oatmeal cookies

If you are looking for something nice and crumbly along with a rich layer of icing on top then you should go ahead with the I'd pumpkin cookies!

Packed with oatmeal, it is healthy as well. Bake it right away!

11. Pumpkin s'mores cookies

We are talking about the extraordinary pumpkin s'mores cookies! Crumbly, crunchy and delightful, you should give it a try for sure.

And if you are looking for something customized then this one is the best to indulge in during the holidays.

12. Brown butter maple pecan cookies

Ah, what an incredible idea! The brown butter-enriched cookies are exactly what you need for a treat!

Drizzled with maple syrup and crunchy pecans, these cookies are ready to adorn the table right away.

So shall we get started then?

13. The best soft gingerbread cookies

Savory and rich, these cookies are exactly the best thing when you wish to indulge in the warmth of the falls!

Gorgeous and tempting, this is a wonderful treat for the holiday season. And you can bake it even as a beginner.

14. Marbled fall leaf cut-out cookies

If you are good at baking then we challenge you to go ahead with the fall cut-out cookies.

Delectable and crumbly, these are simply the best and ready in no time! Crunchy and flooded with a thick layer of icing, you must try it out!

15. Cinnamon sugar apple butter pie

The cozy and rich cinnamon sugar apples butter pies are one of a kind. The subtle cinnamon essence is gooey and loaded with great taste!

So what are you wishing for? Make it today.

16. Pumpkin spice snickerdoodles

The crunchy seasonal autumn snickerdoodles are another wonderful idea to relish during the holidays.

The fall season recipe makes the holidays even more special for you.

And if you are baking cookies for the first time then these cookies are exactly the right thing to indulge in!

17. Sweet and tender salted caramel cookies

Topped with tender salted caramel frosting, the sweet and tender cookies with a savory flavor taste so good!

Dreamy, rich, and crumbly, these cookies are perfect to serve on the table as you have some guests over.

18. Maple sugar cookies

The combination of maple and sugar in these cookies turns them into a sheer source of delight for the taste buds.

Shaped like leaves, these cookies are the best treat to opt for. So shall we then?

19. Sea salt butterscotch pretzel cookies

The sea salt butterscotch pretzel cookies are the ultimate treat of the season!

Cozy, crunchy, and savory, you will surely thank us later for the idea!

Well, after all, it is Thanksgiving and you ought to indulge in its blissful taste.

20. The best pecan pie cookies

If you are looking for something nice and crunchy then these pecan pie cookies are the best thing for you!

And if you are a beginner wondering what can go wrong, let us assure you this one is pretty fuss-free.

Other ideas you should check out: Vegan Halloween Cookies, Christmas Filled Cookies, Valentines Day Cookies Recipes, Thanksgiving Desserts for Kids, Christmas Cookies Recipes, Christmas Fruit Salads, Thanksgiving Fruit Salad Recipes, Instant Pot Pork Chop Recipes, Easy Christmas Cider Recipes, Halloween Pumpkin Soup Recipes